Anal Butt Plugs

Top 5 Best Tail Butt Plugs Reviewed In 2023

Show me someone who doesn’t like butt stuff and I’ll show you a liar. Whether some people care to admit it or not, anal stimulation is extremely intense and amazingly pleasurable.

That’s why products like prostate beads and butt plugs have become so popular. Both options make it easier to experience bootyful orgasms, but only one can be worn with flair.

Butt plugs with tails are a unique type of sex toy that we don’t see as often as we should. With whimsical features and anatomical dimensions, these devices are designed to make you cum from your bum while looking totally adorbs.

So, if these things aren’t seen very much then what’s the problem?

As it turns out, picking the best one can be kinda tough.

The Top 5 Best Butt Plugs With Tails In 2023:

At this point, there are more butt plugs with tails than there ever has been before. But therein lies the problem. How do you know which one to buy?

Here are my top five suggestions for your consideration:

#1. The DOMINIX Deluxe Faux Fox Tail – Best Tail Butt Plug Overall


This is one of the sex toy industry’s largest ass play devices, plus it has an extremely cute faux fox fail attached at the end. The entire thing measures 4 generous inches in insertable length with a fat five-inch circumference. The furry tail then features ombre coloring for maximum realism, and it’s incredibly soft as well.

Meanwhile, back at the plug, you get rigid stainless-steel that’s polished to a shine. Together, those factors alone are why the DOMINIX Deluxe Faux Fox Tail is such a hit.

It even comes with its own carrying case you can get be the fanciest fox in the forest. And while the inside doesn’t have any sophisticated vibrating motors nor does the outside have a particularly spectacular shape, the plug itself is weighted to ensure the most pleasure possible from a simple sex toy with typical curves.

It also has a flared base to prevent your overly excited ass from swallowing it whole, so there’s that.

PRO: It’s ideal for butt plug pros and for people who enjoy anal stretching.

CON: It’s not fully submersible in water with the tail attached.


#2. The Frisky Faux Fur Fox Tail Butt Plug


Folks who aren’t very familiar with ass play might not be so quick to stick a large animal tail between their butt cheeks. So, the market invented toys like the Frisky Faux Fur Fox Tail to help ease people into major kink.

Not only is it sized and shaped in a peculiar way, but it’s also covered in skin-safe silicone to make it appropriate for all body types and any water-based lube you can find. The pointy tip paired with the mid-sized undulating shaft means customizable pleasure and tailored insertion.

And since newbies want to experience it all before choosing their favorite activities, this toy features a removable vibrating bullet to make it easier.

Just switch on the bullet to feel deep, rumbling stimulation within the innermost walls of your anus, or take it out to feel something more natural altogether. Either way, this pretty little plug is surprisingly practical while still being adorable with its poufy white tail. It also comes with the batteries included so you can get going right away (plus it’s 100% waterproof).

PRO: It’s ideal for long-term wear and anal endurance training.

CON: The vibrating bullet only has one pleasure setting.

#3. The Playful Bunny Tail Butt Plug


If you’re looking for something sexy and playful, then you’ve come to the right place. The Playful Bunny Tail is a unique butt plug that’s covered in hot pink faux fur and designed to look make you look like a naughty little rabbit.

It measures only 2.5 inches in insertable length, which means it’s not too big but not too small either. The girth is around 3.5 inches at the widest point though, so you don’t have to worry about it slipping too far inside your cave.

It doesn’t vibrate or anything like that, but it does feature a semi-flexible shaft to help you tackle the sweet spot more efficiently. That tiny detail also enhances the pleasure because it moves slightly when you do, meaning things can get pretty sexy if you wear it while masturbating with other sex toys or while being penetrated by a vaginal device.

Meanwhile, the PBT is easy to clean because it’s splash proof and made from high-quality, hypoallergenic materials.

PRO: It’s ideal for exhibitionism and has a tapered bulb for fast insertion/removal.

CON: The size may not be substantial enough for some users.


#4. The DOMINIX Deluxe Faux Fur Glass Butt Plug With Tail


Although this bad boy is marketed as “beginner-friendly,” anyone who starts out on the DOMINIX Deluxe Faux Fur Glass Plug will be disappointed with everything that follows.

That’s because it’s one of the most luxurious tail butt plugs on today’s shelves, with a Borosilicate glass insert that’s attached to fine furry material – all of which is designed to look like a fox’s hind end. It has the crucial flared based as well, giving you even more freedom to experiment without worrying about slippage or shattering.

You know what metal and glass mean, don’t you? They mean temperature play for days. This device can be quickly warmed or cooled under running water.

Plus, damn near any lube in your stash will work with it because of the non-porous construction. Measuring 21 inches in total length, with 17 of that being the tail alone, you get 4 inches of insertable length and 4.5 inches of girth when go this route.

PRO: It’s ideal for sex toy collectors and for those who have sensitivities to metal.

CON: The tail’s fur could be a little more attractive if you ask me.


#5. The Crystal Delights Bunny Butt Plug With Tail


You won’t hear a lot of talking back when you shove the Crystal Delights Bunny Tail in you or someone else’s ass. That’s not just because it’s fucking adorable either.

It’s because this toy comes with two separate bulbs of varying sizes to ensure the wearer’s ultimate pleasure. One bulb is 2.8 inches in insertable length and the other offers 2.9 inches. Both have distinct girths as well, with 1.3 inches and 1.5 inches, respectively. The flanged base is a nice touch too.

This butt plug with a tail is plush and perky, with a solid shaft that pinpoints the p-spot through enhanced ergonomics. It’s easy to clean, easy to love, and even easier to disassemble.

Simply press the magnet on the side and the tail pops off of the base. You can then swap it out for a different size or leave the tail off completely. This versatile and vivacious sex toy is also made out of borosilicate glass, so it lasts forever and feels amazing against the skin after being heated up or cooled down.

PRO: It’s ideal for collectors because it’s handmade in the USA and therefore one-of-a-kind.

CON: The dimensions and design may not be what some people are looking for.

Keep in mind that each one of these anal sex toys comes with a limited warranty from the manufacturer. That means you can buy with confidence or experiment without worrying too much.

Just be sure to register your device within 30 days of the purchase date to avoid cancellation.

How To Choose The Right Tail Butt Plug

Choosing the butt plug that’s right for you isn’t as easy as some people make it sound. Truth be told, there’s a lot of thinking and planning that needs to be done. This tail will be inserted into your anus and then left there for long periods.

So, you can’t be messing around when it comes to shopping for one. Here’s what to do instead:

Know what you desire.

These sex toy companies aren’t going to define pleasure for you, although some of them might try. That means you’ll have to come prepared with a few fantasies of your own. Do you want a device that’s suitable for long-term wear or are you looking for something a little more fashionable?

With tail plugs, the possibilities are virtually endless.

Respect what you need.

Just because you have a healthy sexual appetite doesn’t mean all devices are good for your body.

So, try to find an agreement between your fantasies and the realities of your world. If that means buying something smaller, do it. If it means choosing something that an extra-thick shaft, so be it. The point is to respect your asshole’s wishes.

Understand the category.

Realize that butt plugs with tails are a unique species with a cult following that takes design and insertion very seriously. There are several categories too.

Like most underground or niche sexual kinks, anal stimulation toys with bonus features like animal tails for roleplaying are an essential element to any balanced breakfast…in bed. So, find out what you’re getting into (or rather, what’s getting into you).

Compare features.

When you get to this stage in the game, you’ll most likely know exactly what you came for. You’ll also be able to track product updates, and you even can compare existing products with ease and efficiency.

Therefore, start getting your erotic education today because things can change very quickly in this fast-paced industry and you don’t want to be the last to know.

Use trial and error.

Nothing is ever perfect, so don’t wait to buy your butt plugs until you find something flawless. It’s not possible; it will never happen. Instead, make a list of your ideal toy’s top 10 most important traits.

Then, compare features until you’ve checked off a few boxes. The device with the most boxes checked wins. It’s a simple as that.

To find the anal toys that are most tailored to your specifications, follow a buyer’s guide like the one below.

The Butt Plug With Tail Buyer’s Guide

This shit makes me nervous too. On one hand, you’ll spare no expense to get the insertable tail of your dreams.

On the other hand, every manufacturer claims to make exactly that. Mathematically speaking, that’s bullshit. They can’t all be amazing, so here’s how you tell.

What Is a Tail Butt Plug?

These are like traditional butt plugs but with more personality. They’re like anal beads with a college degree in Fine Arts. They’re simple yet elegant, and practical yet quirky.

Insertable anal tails are, indeed, one of the most elite of all sex toys on today’s market. That’s mostly because you have to be a pro to find the right one and use it correctly – or use it at all, for that matter.

As a device that’s designed specifically for anal penetration, butt plugs slide into the anus and sit there until either the user or their partner pulls it out.

There’s usually a pull tab of some sort to prevent slipping, and in this case that “pull tab” is creative. Sex tails are made to look and/or feel like various animals – bunnies, kittens, deer, etc. And as cray-cray as that sounds, it’s actually pretty sexy.

The Main Features

No two booty plugs are the same, and the ones with tails are no exception. In fact, I’d venture to say that there are even more fuzzy sockets than traditional ones because of how much imagination is involved. It doesn’t take a genius to understand that, and you don’t need a degree in engineering to use one either.

So, despite the varieties in design, here’s what all of them have in common:

Bulbous Shaft

Nothing says “stay put” like a shaft that’s good and plump. So, these devices almost always feature shafts that curve to meet the walls of your anus. That way, the toy doesn’t slip while you’re wearing it and it doesn’t hurt when you pull it out either.

Meanwhile, the shafts can be made from a wide variety of different materials, from stainless-steel and silicone to thermoplastic elastomer (TPE) and polyvinyl chloride (PVC).

Rounded Tip

Shoving something into your ass can be hard because the sphincter muscles work to push things out instead of pulling them in. That’s why so many anal toys are designed with rounded or pointy tips. The extra attention to ergonomics makes a major difference with or without lube.

Also, it’s especially important for people whose assholes are sensitive or who have never tried butt stuff before (or so they say).

Fuzzy Tail

Say this three times fast: The tail leaves a telltale trail that’ll get you nailed.

Unlike traditional butt plugs which simply sit inside the anus and sometimes feature a shiny jewel or finger loop, tail plugs feature fuzzy balls of faux fur and/or cotton-polyester blend materials. There’s either a pretty poof or a sleek and slender slither on the other end.

So, this device is more than perfect for long nights of creative passion and roleplaying.

As good as all that sounds, there are a few more things you’ll have to sort out before deciding on the top tail butt plug. It’s best not to rush into this shit, even if your brown eye is winking right at you.

Some manufacturers will take advantage of your lack of knowledge in this area, so let this information sink in.

What To Look For

No two sex toys are the same, even if they have similar features and are made to function exactly alike. And since butt plugs with tails are designed specifically for internal pleasure and external fun, they’re typically crafted individually and can be found in almost any shape or size.

In fact, there’s even a model that looks like a whale penis, but let’s forget about that for now.

The best way to find the best device is to know what you’re looking for. So, gander at these four factors before putting anything in your cart:


Size matters, especially when it comes to anal penetration. And while your kink and experience level are important, they shouldn’t be the only thing you consider here. Keep in mind that these things are meant to be kept inside your anus for extended periods.

So, don’t get anything too small or too large because it could get lost or stuck in your ass.


We are living in a material world, and that means the stuff your sex toys are made of is important.

Back in day, you’d find devices crafted out of all sorts of things and some of them weren’t very good for the body. And while a lot of manufacturers have since moved to more luxurious materials, it’s still a good idea to double check.


It may not be a big deal to everybody, but the color and craftsmanship of the tail hanging out of your ass can affect how much pleasure you derive from it.

Think of it this way: If you’re trying to roleplay a specific way and your butt plug tail is lame, you’ll be distracted by that and might not experience the orgasms you came here for.

Bonus Features

Some tail butt plugs have integrated bonus features such as vibrating bullets or internal motors. They provide an elevated sensation that stimulates more than just the anal canal. With one click of a button, they can buzz to life and attack the p-spot with insane precision.

Plus, you can turn them on or off based on how you plan to play today. Choose wisely.

Knowing what to look for is only half the battle, though. You also need to know which things to avoid. Manufacturers will only tell you the good stuff, so try to approach this purchase like a pro.

Things to avoid

Part of finding what you need is avoiding what you don’t. However, no sex toy maker is going to tell you that their product won’t cut the mustard. Instead, they’ll say that everyone loves it and that it’s a top-quality device made through diligent processing.

Truth be told, some of these bastards are just slapped together. And here’s how you can tell:

Potential Allergens

Stay away from anything that’s made out of latex because it could cause an allergic reaction you aren’t prepared for. Moreover, try to avoid products with parabens and phthalates too.

Those ingredients not only suck for the skin but they’re also not compatible with some lube types and they break down easily as well. Go for stainless-steel, silicone, tempered glass, TPE, or PVC is possible.

Loose Fittings

Most butt plugs with tails consist of several pieces fashioned together – one for the insertable part and the other for the portion that hangs down your butt crack.

However, if the connective fittings are loose or made from low-quality materials, the plug could snap off in your ass during rough sex. If that sounds horrible, compare it to just doing a quick inspection. Not so bad, eh?

Weak Power Settings

Try not to get anything that has weak batteries or feeble motors because your sessions could become extremely frustrating if that happens. Plugs with poor power only tickle the taint and usually cannot produce the intense orgasms you’re looking for.

So, determine the power output and then compare that to the other devices in your shopping cart. Choose the one with the most juice.

Uncomfortable Shapes

Although most anal stim plugs feature similar shaft shapes and body-friendly sizes, that’s not always the case. There are some manufacturers who try to win consumer hearts with crazy designs that – while looking good on a shelf – probably don’t feel very good inside.

So, determine whether you’re a collector or an experiencer and then go from there. Just try not to get too crazy, okay?

Regardless of what you’re using one of these things for, understanding that nothing is perfect certainly helps.

After all, if you wait until the world’s first flawless sex toy gets invented, you’re going to be waiting a long time. Instead of longsuffering for no good reason, consider the inevitable pros and cons and the decide what’s acceptable/unacceptable to you.

The Pros & Cons of Wearing Tail Plugs In Your Butt

Believe it or not, there are some drawbacks to playing with your backside. Doctors and sex professionals know this, but maybe you don’t.

So, here are the pros and cons you need to consider before judging any butt plug:


  • It looks amazing.
  • You can use it for pleasure or pain.
  • The tails are customizable.
  • It can be used with another device.


  • It can become lodged or lost
  • There’s a risk of bacterial contamination

To manage or eliminate some of the cons mentioned here, keep your device clean and never use it for vaginal penetration unless you’ve used an antibacterial cleaning substance on it first.

Meanwhile, choose a plug with extra safety features to prevent slippage and accidents.

Where To Find The Best Butt Plugs With Tails On The Internet?

LOVEHONEY – Our top recommended online sex toy shop that offers you the best prices, fastest and most discreet shipping on the internet.

The Final Verdict

You can have tons of fun with a butt plug that has a tail attached to it, but that’s only if you know which one to choose. At the same time, you must learn how to tell them all apart, and then determine what sort of experiences you want to have with yours tonight.

Once those things are handled, the best tail butt plugs should reveal themselves, and most likely, they’re already on this list.

Tail Butt Plug FAQs

Q: How do I clean a toy used for butt stuff?

A: Cleaning your anal sex toys is crucial, so this is a good question to ask. Most of the time, you can get away with rinsing your device in war, fresh water before applying an antibacterial soap or sex toy cleaning solution to the surface. Just make sure your cleaning supplies are both non-abrasive and hypoallergenic.

Meanwhile, always check the owner’s manual for specifical instructions on how to care for your device. Some may require additional steps or special precautions in storage.

Q: Is there a special way to store a butt plug with a tail?

A: Keeping your favorite sex toys in safe storage is important because it can help prevent damage and ensure your privacy. It also protects the surface of your butt plugs from becoming covered in environmental debris or bacteria from coming in contact with other objects.

So, always put your plugs in a safe spot when you’re done. This might include a bedside drawer, a medicine cabinet, or even a naughty chest.

Either way, make sure it’s isolated in its own container. And as always, check the owner’s manual for specific instructions on how to properly store it.

Q: Which type of personal lubricant am I supposed to use for anal sex?

A: Contrary to popular belief, you can’t use whatever type of lube you want regardless of what you’re doing. Instead, you must match the lube’s ingredients with your skin type and the materials on your device. For anal sex especially, certain lubricants perform better than others. That’s because the anus doesn’t produce its own lubrication, so it needs something long-lasting and gentle for support.

So, try to stick with water-based lubes if you can. And if not, never pair silicone sex toys with silicone-based lubes or else.

Q: What happens if my butt plug gets stuck?

A: In the not-so-rare instance that your butt stuff becomes lodged in your crack, try to get it out by bearing down with your pelvic muscles while pulling gently on the device. This may prove difficult if you’ve used lots of lube, so try grabbing a dry towel to boost your grip.

If that fails, seek medical attention immediately. And you may not have to go to the emergency room either. In some cases, you can contact your doctor’s on-call nurse for a private walk-through in your own home.

Q: How do I fix my device if it breaks or comes apart?

A: Hopefully, your devices are robust and durable enough to stay intact while you enjoy them. But if something comes apart, only try to fix it if the manual includes instructions or if the issue is simple.

Otherwise, contact the manufacturer for more information on how to repair a broken butt plug. And if you’ve registered the warranty that came with your device, you might even be eligible for a full refund or replacement.

Q: Do butt plugs hurt?

A: Despite the word on the streets, anal sex is not supposed to hurt. That means using a butt plug should be pleasurable from start to finish, with the only pain being psychological during routine BDSM sessions where humiliation is at work. Ass play is a sophisticated form of kink that requires many steps and much preparation.

Still, it’s not associated with getting hurt because it feels amazing when you do it right. So, if playing with your butt plugs causes you pain or discomfort in any way, either stop playing like that or see a doctor because you could a more serious problem than a lack of skills and equipment.

Q: Is there a way to warm my device before sticking it in my ass?

A: Yes. You can warm up the surface of your stainless-steel butt plugs in just a few minutes. Simply run the metal portion under hot water for about 60 seconds.

Afterward, apply a generous amount of lube and then take it to brown town. You can also use friction to warm it up. Just rub it between your hands or stick it in your mouth for a rapid temperature increase.

Q: How do I clean the tail though?

A: Most tail butt plugs let you detach the tail from the plug for easier cleaning. However, cleaning the ones that don’t detach can be tricky. You have to separate the parts and then wash them carefully with soap and water.

For the furry part, you might have to hang it up to dry. When it’s done, fluff or brush it (if you can) before you reattach it to the base. For more specific instructions, consult the owner’s manual.

Add Comment

Click here to post a comment

Lovense Max